It is widely known that Carmel has become a favorite for wine enthusiasts. The tasting rooms where you can sample the wines can be found all over downtown.
What pairs better with some of these wines than an equally well-crafted chocolate?
Peggy and Bob Whitted have been making chocolate since 1986. After years of honing their craft in various candy shops, they acquired Pieces of Heaven in The Barnyard in 1995, and they’ve been turning out their confections ever since.
“Both of us have always had a sweet tooth,” Peggy says. “But once we started making them we realized we had a knack for it.”
Making chocolate is a delicate process – one that requires time, patience and a deft touch. It’s like wine in that way. Bob long ago mastered the process of tempering. In order to produce a consistently smooth and glossy coat, chocolate is heated in a rotating kettle. Much like the kneading of dough, tempering is a hands-on process. And a lot can go wrong. Let the temperatures slip from a certain point, for example, and the chocolate will slump.
Bob just celebrated his 84th birthday. But if you glance in the front window of the candy shop, most days you’ll still find him at the tempering table. And it’s not just chocolate that they’ve mastered.
“I love what I do,” he says as he begins another batch of his legendary caramel. “Everything we make here is hand-crafted and made right here in the shop. You can’t get this stuff just anywhere.”
The menu extends to toffees to clusters of roasted nuts, caramels, kettle corn, brittles and dairy creams. Yet for the Whitteds, it comes back to chocolate.
It almost seems as if the couple has been dipped in the stuff. Peggy studied confectionery at RCI Candy School in Erie, Pennsylvania, and over the years she found her niche in truffle-making.
“We offer about 26 different truffles,” Peggy says. “All are made from scratch with the highest-quality butter, cream and chocolate. It’s hard work, but we’ve always enjoyed it.”
Despite online promises of the ease of truffle recipes, they can be quite fidgety to make. The couple offers classes in these and other treats, and have taught young students about the history of chocolate (think ancient Mesoamerica) and art. Both earned the title Master Confectioner, Emeritus.
Yet for all it produces and stocks, for all the people it has engaged, Pieces of Heaven is a decidedly small shop. The 800-square-foot confectionery first opened by Katherine Hoshor in 1987 makes the most of its space.
“Making our chocolates here in the store allows us to control the product that we offer our customers,” Bob says. “And I think our customers appreciate it.”
On any given day there is a steady flow of traffic into the corner candy store. “Our customers are the most loyal we could ever hope for,” Peggy adds. “We’ve shipped our products to people all over the world.”
Pieces of Heaven has endured the test of time in an area that seems to offer more candy per capita than any other county of small communities. There are sweets shops lining Cannery Row and Fisherman’s Wharf in Monterey and there are outlets in malls.
And many are known for longevity – and quality. The British-style shop Cottage of Sweets in Carmel, which both makes and imports treats, opened in 1959. Carousel Candies on Fisherman’s Wharf, long recognized for pulling taffy, has been around for 47 years.
Lula’s Chocolates is a youthful operation, by comparison. But it has already matched its peers in reputation.
Still, the decades of success at Pieces of Heaven is a remarkable achievement. And business is not tapering off. As the Whitteds approach their 30th anniversary in The Barnyard, it’s safe to say they were right about their particular knack.
“Over 30 years in business here in Carmel – it kind of makes for a sweet story,” Bob says with a smile.

(0) comments
Welcome to the discussion.
Log In
Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.