Marina Dunes

Cal Am's proposed slant wells would draw 6.4 millions gallons of water per day from under the beach in Marina; Marina Coast Water District and the city of Marina contend this would harm Marina's groundwater supply. 

The first salvo of a long-anticipated legal battle has arrived: On Oct. 12, Marina Coast Water District filed a lawsuit in state Supreme Court over the California Public Utilities Commission's Sept. 13 approval of California American Water's proposed desalination project in Marina. 

Marina City Attorney Rob Wellington confirms the city of Marina also filed a lawsuit, but that he has not yet seen it (the city hired outside attorneys to handle the litigation). The Weekly has not yet viewed Marina's lawsuit. 

The timing of the lawsuits are little surprise, as the window to take legal action over the CPUC's approval is set to close today, Oct. 15. It is also the first of what could be more lawsuits in the months to come, as the proposed project is open to several points of potential legal attack as Cal Am pursues the required permits before the project can be built. 

Among other things, Marina Coast's lawsuit argues the CPUC—the lead public agency for Cal Am's project—violated the California Environmental Quality Act in approving the project. Marina Coast asks that the court order the CPUC to conduct a more thorough review that considers the potential harm to Marina Coast's groundwater resources and that further analyzes project alternatives.

The lawsuit, which numbers more than 140 pages, enumerates several points to make this contention, and argues that the CPUC made a flawed determination in deciding that the proposed project is the environmentally superior alternative. 

In part, that contention is based on the fact that the CPUC did not consider groundwater modeling conducted by Marina Coast that shows pockets of freshwater in the shallow aquifer by Cal Am's proposed slant wells under the beach. 

Keith Van Der Maaten, Marina Coast's general manager, has long argued that those pockets of freshwater create a bulwark against further seawater intrusion into Marina's 180- and 400-foot aquifers, which comprise nearly half of the district's current water supply. 

The lawsuit also argues that the project's proposed mitigation measures for taking freshwater from the aquifer—Cal Am has agreed to send a comparable amount of freshwater to nearby Castroville, which is also impacted by seawater intrusion—don't mitigate the harm that would be done to Marina's groundwater. 

The lawsuit also alleges that the CPUC's approval violates both the California Constitution and state water law. The crux of those arguments is that the CPUC did not adequately consider an expansion of the Pure Water Monterey recycled water project—which arguably could meet the Monterey Peninsula's water demand for another decade—and that the CPUC ignored potential harm to a groundwater basin that the state considers "critically overdrafted."

In a text message, Cal Am spokeswoman Catherine Stedman says Marina Coast's concerns "have been vetted thoroughly in extensive environmental work conducted by the CPUC and the [Monterey Bay National Marine Sanctuary].

"There has been an objective, complete and considered review of their points which found our project can and should proceed," Stedman continues. "We hope for a quick resolution to their claims, as again they have already been analyzed and ultimately dismissed on both the state and federal level."

No response was immediately available from the CPUC this afternoon; this story will be updated. 

--

Editor's Note 10/15/18 3pm: This story has been updated to include comments from Catherine Stedman. 

(0) comments

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.