Cash Strapped

Tony Scardina, owner of Scardina Builders Inc., lost his office in the fire. Like many tenants, he’s paying more in rent now, even with a sharing arrangement.

Jacey Vickrey had just moved into the Talbott Building in Carmel Valley Village in June; her candle and bodycare business, Lily & Lavender, had flourished to the point that she could move her operation out of her kitchen.

The space held her whole inventory and equipment – jars, candles, essential oils and her great-grandma’s mixer. When she returned on Wednesday, Nov. 11, two weeks after an Oct. 28 fire tore through, the visit confirmed she’d lost virtually everything.

“You go up there and there’s so much debris under your feet,” Vickrey says. “Seeing your life in a different form now is really devastating.”

Having only general liability insurance, she will not receive coverage for the $75,000 in stock wiped out by fire, water and smoke damage.

Now, Vickrey’s back in her kitchen, still trying to fulfill preorders to keep her business afloat. She’s fronted about $10,000 to keep it running, funded primarily from a GoFundMe, family donations and credit cards.

Whether they were there for a few months or decades, business owners have taken a financial hit. According to Monterey County Fire Protection District Division Chief Justin Linquist, their investigation was inconclusive on the cause of the fire.

The fire started in the multi-use office building behind the Center Street Marketplace, and jumped to a nearby residential building, as well as the Talbott Building.

At Olivia & Daisy Books, mold has grown in the carpet of the kid’s reading nook and the inventory of books is unsalvageable from water damage. The business owners lost about $200,000 in inventory, according to a GoFundMe, of which their insurance covers half.

“The insurance gymnastics and forensic inventory audits after the Oct. 28 fire have been a heavy lift, but stepping out from behind the spreadsheets into the human bits of this has been staggering,” bookstore owner Kelsey Boyte writes by email. “There is so much more goodness here than despair.”

In a single unit, Katie Padilla operated her law firm, an artisan retail space called Sanctuary and a FedEx center. She didn’t have insurance beyond general liability insurance, required for tenants in the building, meaning none of her losses will be covered by insurance.

Anthony Davi, who is a broker and partner at A.G. Davi, the property management for the Talbott Building, says they don’t require insurance beyond general liability because they saw it as a barrier to entry.

“As these individuals are relocating and going to new spots, all the costs are so high that they’re making it hard for individuals to open up in new locations,” Davi says. “If you add on the cost and requirement to have liability insurance and personal property insurance to satisfy the owner of the building, it’s maybe not realistic for [tenants].”

Davi says the future of the Talbott building is in limbo. To demolish or rebuild it will depend on what insurance will cover and the cost to rebuild.

The fire has quite literally brought some tenants closer together. Tony Scardina says he moved his office to share with a friend he’s known since he was 5 years old. While their rent has nearly doubled, he’ll now be sharing an office space.

(0) comments

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.