A Year of ICE

A positive effect of the policy change in the eyes of Undersheriff Michael Moore would be that people who are being removed are people who have prior convictions, and therefore, making the county safer.

It’s been a year since Sheriff Steve Bernal launched a pilot program allowing federal immigration agents inside Monterey County Jail to sift through records and determine if inmates may be eligible for deportation based on their criminal records.

Since August 2015, when the policy change was made quietly and without prior public input, 448 individuals with prior convictions have been removed from the jail and at least one person has been taken by mistake, according to U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement spokesman James Schwab. The rate of removing individuals from the jail is 26 times higher than it was before the policy change.

“I think we are good [with the policy],” Undersheriff Michael Moore says. “At this point it is a permanent policy.”

Bernal made the change in the midst of a political debate over the nation’s immigration system, sparked by the shooting death of Kathryn Steinle in San Francisco. A man with a criminal record and an immigration hold that was not honored was charged in her murder. In Monterey County, immigration holds – meaning inmates are held past their sentences to be detained by ICE – are not honored. Instead, ICE agents are allowed access to jail records and notified when someone is about to be released from custody.

For ICE agents to take custody of inmates, they must be present in the jail, Moore says. If ICE agents aren’t on site, jail officials release inmates when they finish serving their sentences, regardless of immigration status.

Moore says 45 percent of the individuals taken from county jail had one or more prior felony convictions, while 55 percent had one or multiple misdemeanors on their record, such as driving under the influence or domestic violence convictions.

While Bernal made the move in the name of public safety, a year later crime statistics do not show a decrease in crime in unincorporated areas of Monterey County. Though felony arrests have declined, property crimes and violent crimes have increased, Moore says, but he cannot pinpoint an exact cause.

Michael Mehr, a Santa Cruz-based immigration attorney, says numerous clients of his have been removed by ICE agents, and sees the policy as having a long-term cost to the community.

“A lot of kids will be growing up without parents,” Mehr says. “Frankly, the argument that it is to increase public safety is very short-sighted.”

Meanwhile, the individuals who have been removed are scheduled for hearings with the Executive Office for Immigration Review in the San Francisco Immigration Court, where a federal judge ultimately determines what their fate will be. The outcomes, Schwab says, can result in deportation back to their country of origin; detention in the privately-funded Mesa Verde Detention Facility, where immigration detainees can sometimes spend years due to a backlog of more than 31,321 immigration cases in the San Francisco court system; or they can be released with GPS-monitored ankle bracelets.

“For security reasons, these people go to different places,” Schwab says, who adds their locations cannot be disclosed to the public due to privacy laws, saying it is for the “general safety of everyone and not about secrecy.”

For this reason, it is difficult to ascertain where the individuals taken from county jail have gone.

(3) comments

James Sullivan

I can understand deporting undocumented persons convicted of violent felonies, but deporting those who are guilty of nothing more than non-violent misdemeanors is just wrong. It needlessly breaks up families and exposes so many of our fellow residents to fear of being snatched away on the smallest pretext. This is lousy public policy and inhumane treatment.

Uma S.T. Beekidding

Hard to believe local law enforcement is part of this corruption.

Mesa Verde is owned by Geo Group.

Geo Group, was formerly Wackenhut, and before that G4S Security Solutions.

DHS contracts with G4S, who had a long term employee named Omar Mateen.

Mateen killed 50 people when he shot up the Pulse Nightclub in Florida.

These people manufacture terror and degradation.

Florida is where GEO is based in the US.

But GEO owns prisons in South Africa, Australia, the UK and other counties.

GEO uses political connections, mostly Republican, to expand the prison population, and increase the money they can collect on government contracts for prisons.

In the US for hundreds of years, when immigrants had status issues, they received a Notice to Appear before and Immigration Judge. Immigration law in the US has a long history of being civil, administrative law. We never had all these"detention centers" for immigrants in the US. For a short period there were Japanese interment camps during WWII, but Congress has made an official apology for these.

Only since the uninvestigated crimes of 9/11, have the Republicans led the way to imprisoning immigrants in detention facilities built and run by Republican campaign contributors, essentially making poverty and the immigrant story, a new profit center for themselves and their pals.

Bernal, I voted for you.

Big mistake.

Clean up your act.

Carole Lindner

The privately-run facility in Bakersfield to which many of the undocumented persons are sent is rife with egregious violations, especially with regards to sexual assault prevention, basic hygiene, right to private communication with counsel and on and on. Enlightening, but scary report:
https://www.ice.gov/sites/default/files/documents/FOIA/2016/mesaVerdeDetentionFacilityBakersfieldCaJan12142016.pdf

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.