On May 10, a family of nine people – six of them undocumented immigrants – were evicted from their two-bedroom apartment in Seaside at San Pablo by the Sea, a 10-building apartment complex on San Pablo Avenue and Baker Street.
In the days prior to that, the family – the last names of whom the Weekly is not disclosing because of their immigration status – had already moved out, because the apartment had become a hotbed of black mold: On a visit to their former home May 8, after the family had moved out but still had keys, the smell of the mold was so bad it was dizzying, and mold was growing along every wall in the small apartment, for which the family was paying $1,595 a month.
Speaking through a translator – Seaside resident Guadalupe Perez – Jorge, the father of the family, says they kept the windows open day and night, “even in the dead of winter.”
He says there was no reason given for the eviction notice, but he suspects it was because he’d complained to management about the mold, which he believes stemmed from a plumbing leak in the apartment above. Jorge’s 15-year-old daughter, Wendy, says it was “like rainfall” in the roof above the shower whenever the upstairs tenants were showering.
At one point, part of the ceiling above the shower came down into the bathtub, and while it was later patched up, the family says the leak was never fixed, and the mold continued to proliferate. At another time, Jorge says, the management painted over the mold on one wall, but the wall was so moist the paint slid down and didn’t dry in place.
For the last few weeks, Jorge and his family have been living out of a hotel room provided by the Monterey County Department of Social Services, and he’s put in applications to several apartments in hopes of finding one before his family becomes homeless.
The situation his family finds itself in highlights challenges in a region with ever-increasing rents, and where some tenants either may not know their rights, or may fear speaking up because they are undocumented.
David Little, a building official with the city of Seaside, says it’s important for residents to put any complaints in writing, and that if a landlord doesn’t remediate the problem within 30 days, the city can get involved if it’s a building code violation – like in this case, presumably, a leaky pipe.
Things like mold or cockroach infestations fall under the purview of the County Environmental Health Bureau. Marni Flagg, a supervisor in that department, says the county works with landlords to make sure a solution is found, and stresses that whether or not a resident is undocumented is irrelevant to the process.
Mold is a particularly tricky issue, Flagg says, because “there’s no legal threshold” for what is considered uninhabitable. “Each individual person has a different reaction to mold,” she adds.
Jorge shared his family’s medical records with the Weekly, which show his daughters have suffered respiratory problems. The report for his 3-year-old daughter, Linda, states “patient will cough persistently, then will vomit.”
Management at San Pablo by the Sea did not respond to a request for comment, and the owner of the building, Arizona-based 1050 South 12th St. LLC, could not be reached for comment.
UPDATE 5/29/18: Jorge's and his family are no longer able to cover the costs of a hotel, and are currently homeless. He has set up a GoFundMe page to for those wanting to help his family find shelter.
(3) comments
I just recently moved out of Bay View Community and had similar problems! The first unit I moved into had a very large mold problem. My son and I started getting sick a month or so after we moved in. While I only had a chronic cough my son suffered from more ailments. My son had to be seen by a doctor for rashes, headaches and upper respiratory problems. Bay View will remedy the problem by covering up the problem with paint or new pieces of sheet rock but that does not eliminate the problem. They will also allow you to move into a different unit but with no compensation or help what so ever. I kept everything away from the walls but still had furniture ruined directly through the floor it was sitting on! I put a de-humidifier in my sons room and that needed to be emptied daily because that is how fast it filled up! Also upon leaving I was charged for carpet that they claimed was brand new, but it was not! I highly recommend you take pictures of everything because they will nickle and dime you to death! They even require you to keep your grass green which cost me an extra $90 per month! These units were built as temporary housing for the military and were only made to last about 30 years. They are well beyond that point and the places should be condemned! Cockroaches, mice, rats, mold, fleas you name it, they got it!
There are a lot of places like this one unfortunately. I moved from the homes in Bay View Community on Coe Ave because of the mold issue. I was getting asthma attacks, headaches and coughed every night. Like these people I left windows open year round, left closet doors open for ventilation and left cabinet doors ajar and still got mold. It's never going to be right until they fix the problems INSIDE the walls. I reported them to the health department but unfortunately all they can do it tell them it's been reported. It does nothing for the people that have been made ill because of it. I lost 2 boxes of family photos and important papers because the black mold ate through the box and they were literally attached to the wall when I moved them. Something has to be done to protect the residents. The Landlords blame the tenants for putting something against a wall but how is the tenant responsible for the wall being full of mold and damp on the INSIDE when the outside looks fine when they move in. It's obvious they've just painted over the last problem. We pay a lot to live here, there should be some responsibility on the part of the landlords to make sure our homes are safe. Now that I've moved, no more asthma attacks, the headaches are gone and I'm not coughing at night, coincidence? I think not!
Thank you, MC Weekly for this article.
The region is in desperate need of quality, affordable housing. The status quo of systematic opposition to increasing and improving housing stock serves the few at the expense of the many.
Looking forward to disrupting that status quo in Seaside.
Welcome to the discussion.
Log In
Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.