DEAD ON ARRIVAL… As a cephalopod columnist, Squid is all too familiar with the phrase “stop the presses.” Squid has an endless supply of ink, so it wouldn’t be a crisis if something needed to be reprinted.

But Squid realizes humans aren’t so fortunate, and it costs time and money to roll the presses, so they better make sure all’s good before the ink hits the paper. Marina resident John DiCarlo, however, called for the Monterey County Elections Department to stop the press – after the ink already dried.

On July 15, the Marina City Council finalized the language for Measure Q, a 7-percent utility users tax on the November ballot. On Sept. 1, DiCarlo filed a petition in Monterey County Superior Court, arguing that the ballot question was misleading.

Measure Q is a general fund tax, meaning it can be used for any city purpose. The measure, and the fliers promoting it, calls it a “911 Emergency, Public Safety and Community Services Measure.” DiCarlo argues it needs to be changed to strictly “City of Marina 7% Utility Users Tax Measure.”

Marina City Attorney René Ortega says the last day for someone to file a timely lawsuit requesting a change was July 27. “Both legally and practically, it is too late for the Council to make any changes to the ballot question,” he says.

Judge Ian Rivamonte agreed, denying DiCarlo’s petition on Sept. 8.

Squid knows deadlines exist for a reason. DiCarlo learned that lesson in the courtroom.

BUZZ OFF… Besides that ever-replenishing ink supply, Squid thinks cephalopods enjoy many advantages compared to their human counterparts, including statocysts instead of ears. Humans are so sensitive to so many sounds at so many frequencies. And that was true at the Monterey Jazz Festival Sept. 25-27 at the Monterey County Fairgrounds, where dozens of acts played a lot of fabulous music.

There was also the persistent sound of commercial and private aircraft overhead thanks to the nearby Monterey Regional Airport, and a flight path that went directly over the main stage. Add to the mix the jets participating in the California International Airshow Salinas, held on the same weekend.

But most people seemed to be talking about something else: a drone hovering over the main stage on Friday night. Some angry audience members made their way straight to MJF Managing Director Bobbie Young, who assured them it was some kind of rogue pest – nobody affiliated with the festival would fly such a big, loud drone so obnoxiously close to the stage.

A few hours later, Young had an update for Squid’s colleague: It was indeed their own team, perhaps gathering footage of a crowd covering their ears to block the buzz – not the best material for promoting a music festival.

(1) comment

Hans Ongchua

One must readily concede to Squid that, in the rigid halls of the justice system, the calendar is a merciless master. Deadlines are deadlines.

However, let us not allow a mere procedural technicality to obscure a much more profound truth: JOHN DICARLO DID PRECISELY THE RIGHT THING. What is more, had he simply filed his paperwork a few days sooner, it is highly probable that THE JUDGE WOULD HAVE HANDED HIM A DECISIVE VICTORY.

The law, as it happens, was FIRMLY on Mr. DiCarlo’s side. The courts in California have grown quite intolerant of this particular brand of political sleight-of-hand. When a city proposes a general tax - meaning the funds can be deposited into the general coffers and spent on absolutely anything the city desires - precedent dictates that officials cannot dress up the ballot question with wildly popular buzzwords.

We need only look to the 2012 case of “McDonough v. Superior Court”, where the California Court of Appeal struck down a San Jose ballot measure for doing precisely this. The court rightly ruled that PACKING A BALLOT QUESTION WITH POPULAR SERVICES LIKE POLICE AND FIRE IS IMPERMISSIBLY PARTISAN. Even more recently, in this year’s “Douglas Partello v. Lourdes Lopez” case out of Ventura County, a judge dragged the city of Oxnard into court and forced them to STRIP THE MISLEADING LANGUAGE from their own tax measure in favor of NEUTRAL WORDING.

The legal precedent is firmly established: judges will not tolerate deceptive ballot manipulation.

For those who doubt the prevalence of such chicanery, I highly recommend a rather illuminating 2022 report from the Santa Clara County Civil Grand Jury. It bears the appropriately blunt title, "If You Only Read the Ballot, You're Being Duped."

https://santaclara.courts.ca.gov/system/files/if-you-only-read-ballot-response-city-san-jose_0.pdf

The true tragedy of this affair is not a missed deadline; it is the unfortunate consequence that must inevitably follow. Because the buzzer sounded before the referee could throw the flag, A GREAT MANY GOOD CITIZENS OF MARINA ARE GOING TO BE THOROUGHLY MISLED when they cast their votes this November. They will read those carefully curated buzzwords and naturally assume they are guaranteeing money for 911 emergencies and public safety, blissfully unaware that they are, in fact, handing the City Council a blank check.

Mr. DiCarlo performed a noble public service by attempting to halt this charade. He may have been late to the courthouse, but he was entirely right on the merits.

Since the courts are now procedurally barred from fixing the ballot, one can only hope that the voters of Marina will have the good sense to see through the illusion themselves.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.