His Three Daughters: Tortilla Soup celebrates the trials and tribulations of family and food.
"This is a movie about communication: how we use food to communicate, how food brings us together and pulls us apart, how food is totemic and inter-generational, how it changes in tune with the culture." I wrote those words in 1994 in my review of Ang Lee''s wonderful Chinese film Eat Drink Man Woman. That description rings just as true for Tortilla Soup, the American-made remake that transposes Lee''s story about a Taiwanese family to Mexican-American Los Angeles. It''s amazing how similar the key elements of the two movies are, yet how distinctive they are as a result of the different cultures they portray.
In Tortilla Soup, Hector Elizondo plays the family patriarch Martin, a retired master chef and a longtime widower, who lives in the family home with his three grown daughters. The only house rules are that everyone gather for the Sunday dinner that Martin, who is still a great chef despite having lost his sense of taste and smell, grandly prepares each week. (The movie is a foodie''s delight, with loving close-ups of the details of meal preparations that destine the movie to become one of those classics whose recipes are imitated by fans and aficionados.) These days, however, whenever the family gathers for Sunday dinner it seems that one or another of the daughters has "an announcement," which tends to result in unfinished meals and shattered dishware.
Like the daughters in Eat Drink Man Woman, one is an repressed spinster chemistry teacher (Elizabeth Peña); one is a well-educated, fast-track business exec (Jacqueline Obradors); and the youngest is a rebellious-for-the-hell-of-it teen (Tamara Mello). The movie cross-cuts between events in the lives of Martin and his girls, and just when the viewer begins wondering if all this colorful but inconsequential material will ever lead to anything of substance, it does--just as it did in Ang Lee''s film before.
Every would-be chef knows that it''s nearly impossible to predict the ultimate outcome of any meal. And so it is with Tortilla Soup. While the lives of these characters don''t necessarily turn out as planned, the surprises are what provide the extra flavor and delight. By showing the father''s desire for his daughters to achieve more than he did in life, Tortilla Soup garnishes the story with a slice of the American-immigrant experience. (Ironically, the daughter whose interests most closely mirror his own is the one he encourages to strike out on her own.)
Only a quite over-the-top character played by Raquel Welch strikes any false note. Otherwise, Tortilla Soup is a real chef''s special.
Tortilla Soup... (* * * * )
Rated: PG-13, 103 min.Directed by: Maria Ripoll
Starring: Jacqueline Obradors, Raquel Welch, Elizabeth Peña, Paul Rodriguez, Hector Elizondo, Constance Marie, Tamara Mello, Nikolai Kinski
Where: Monterey State Theater
When: See Movie Times
(0) comments
Welcome to the discussion.
Log In
Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.