Updated

After the votes were tallied, and most of a big cake adorned with Carmel’s city seal had been devoured, mayoral candidate Adam Moniz, 33, and his supporters adjourned to a quiet gathering. An independent energy consultant and former staffer at inside-the-beltway law firm and lobby group Patton Boggs, Moniz carried two statements in his pocket – one he’d give if he won, and the other, congratulating McCloud, thanking his supporters, and promising to remain active in Carmel politics.

It wasn’t much of a surprise which one he ultimately used, but it was surprising how close he came to reciting the other. As expected, Mayor Sue McCloud won a sixth term in office Tuesday, April 13, in what appeared to be a strong turnout in the city’s most hotly contested race in recent memory. Despite his newcomer status, Moniz represented her first serious challenger in at least eight years, and lost 789 to 674. That turn of events, along with a resounding win for City Council candidate Jason Burnett, also 33 – who bagged 1,081 votes, leaving his two veteran opponents in the dust – sent a clear message things are stirring in Carmel. Meanwhile Paula Hazdovac won re-election to her fourth term as the second-place finisher with 646 votes, while Gerard Rose picked up 588 votes, losing his battle to remain on the council after a decade in office.

Provisional and vote-by-mail ballots that were dropped off at the polls on election day had not been counted by the Weekly’s deadline, but it didn’t appear they’d make a difference in the results.

Burnett’s party was livelier than Moniz’s, with a younger crowd eating cake, drinking wine and hobnobbing with a handful of Peninsula politicos, including County Supervisors Dave Potter and Jane Parker, and Congressman Sam Farr’s wife, Shari.

“I’m surprised how many votes I received,” Burnett said.

Burnett – and to a lesser extent Moniz – appeared to galvanize voters like Warren Finch, who cast a ballot at the Sunset Center Tuesday for both challengers. “I’m hoping for new thoughts and healthy debate,” Finch said, adding that that he’s been unhappy with the uniformity of opinion among the mayor and council members.

In recent years, unanimous City Council votes have been the norm in Carmel, and council members were also of one mind on the election. All backed McCloud, Hazdovac and Rose. Rose expressed the sentiment wordlessly by wearing each of their oversized buttons on his sport coat. “I’m disappointed,” he said of his defeat before quickly exiting the crowded council chambers.

What will it mean to have Burnett, a former EPA official who blew the whistle on the Bush Administration’s unwillingness to act on climate change, as a councilmember? McCloud said, “I really don’t want to speculate. I have to think about it and let it all sink in.”

Retired Carmel businessman and Rose’s campaign treasurer Merv Sutton said the results were completely unexpected. “I’m very surprised that it’s that close in the mayor’s race,” he said. “It doesn’t show a lot of confidence in the council and mayor.”

Burnett recently told the Weekly that if elected, he would immediately investigate the sexual harassment allegations against City Manager Rich Guillen, emphasizing that it’s essential that Carmel City Hall be a safe workplace.

“He can do that,” Guillen said after the votes were counted Tuesday night. “That’s his right as a councilmember.” Asked about text messages Guillen allegedly sent to on-leave Human Resources Manager Jane Miller saying the City Council doesn’t know what it takes to run the city, Guillen would only say, “It’s alleged. Let the court decide.”

Council incumbents Ken Talmage and Karen Sharp also showed up to congratulate Burnett, but Hazdovac, Rose and McCloud did not.

“It’s a generational change,” said local Democratic Party leader Vinz Koller, who stressed he was celebrating Burnett’s victory as a Carmel resident, not a party official. “You see, we’re not a bunch of old fogies,” he said.

The new council will be sworn in April 20.