The credentials on Katherine Marren’s business card should say it all: PGA Teaching Professional Lead Instructor, Golf for Women Top 50 Teacher, member of the Golf For Women instruction panel. And Marren works for the Pebble Beach Company, one of the best golf resorts in the world.
What her card doesn’t say is that she’s nice enough to be patient with complete beginners like me, and also willing to disclose the really important stuff, like how to carry a golf bag without looking like a total fool.
After receiving a set of Ping clubs from my grandfather a few Christmases ago, I’ve managed just four lessons with Marren in four years. None of this is Marren’s fault: I’ve lacked the commitment due to a variety of excuses, not the least of which is it feels like a time suck and essentially a man’s sport. For me, there’s something intimidating about stepping on a golf course, like going to a party I haven’t been invited to.
Marren wants to break down that psychological barrier. She focuses on demystifying the sport while building up confidence, especially in her women clients.
“Women are intimidated and they have a lot of fear,” she says. “A lot of them come to the game because they want to play with their significant other and they are worried about keeping up. They will say, ‘I’m not going to be any good.’ I’m trying to get them to enjoy the game and process rather than worrying about just hitting a good shot.”
For the most part, it works. Some of her confidence, though not necessarily her talent, radiates through me.
But as I stand inside a tent at Spyglass Hill in Pebble Beach on a rainy January morning, wielding an orange Styrofoam “noodle,” I question her methods. As she smiles and encourages me to swing the noodle at the dimpled white ball nestled on a piece of Astroturf in front of me, I wonder if I’m on Candid Camera. After all, Marren is videotaping my antics. If that’s not bad enough, after each awkward swing I have to watch her computer screen play me against Tiger Woods, and not only does he have the obvious advantage over me, he’s not golfing with a noodle either.
Then Marren has the computer do a slow motion version of my noodle swing, in forward and reverse, over and over again, while I wonder if she’s punishing me for some reason.
“I know you think this is silly,” she says, reading my mind. “But look at what a great swing you did with the noodle.”
She hits a few keys on her keyboard, and voila! My swing with an actual nine iron is on the screen next to the video of me swinging the noodle.
It’s a distressing, if accurate, observation. I play a damn good game of noodle golf, but I suck at the actual thing.
Not that Marren would ever say so.
As patient as she is encouraging, Marren manages to find the positive in the undeniably dorky positioning I create with my body and the club.
“I really like the ‘L’ you made with that backswing,” she says. “Don’t worry about the ball.”
But even though I am trying to remember a myriad of instructions at once—grip, body tilt, foot positioning, hip angle, wrist angle, eye gaze, the “L” shape of the club and my arms—I am really just focusing on one thing: not whiffing the ball. I forget what I’m doing and try to smack it.
Marren diplomatically explains to me this is the biggest mistake beginning golfers make. She puts a gloved hand over mine and has me feel the correct swing. She says to pretend there is a wall of glass in front of me. Rather than breaking the “glass”, I must keep the arc of the club in the correct plane.
It helps. She films me again. It’s a little better. We try it again. I break the glass.
With that, she takes my club from me and I am demoted to noodle golf again.
A few weeks later we are at the driving range at Pebble Beach. I’ve forgotten everything we went over at the last lesson, but Marren quickly breaks it down for me again.
After almost an hour of practice swings, and 60-yard hits down the driving range, Marren takes me to the Peter Hay course across the street. Rated a par three, the course is a comfortable size for beginners. But we’re running out of time and get chuckles from the attendant when we sign up to play only the first hole.
I grab the wrong club from my bag—a six, not the nine iron—and line myself up at the tee. Taking a deep breath, I remember Marren’s instructions to relax. I twist back into my “L”, then let the club go with a whoosh.
“Oh my God!” Marren shouts, as the ball drops neatly a few feet from the hole.
“Nice shot,” says a man passing behind us.
Since we haven’t practiced putting yet, I can’t actually sink the ball into the hole, but that’s enough for me. Marren insists on taking my picture, and I smile smugly at the attendant on the way out.