Agata Popęda here. In this week’s edition of the Weekly, my colleague Squid pointed out a change coming to the Monterey Museum of Art. It’s a small change that will affect only a tiny fraction of the community—the docents of the museum, a group of about 25 individuals who traditionally give group tours and engage with visitors to the galleries.
According to the new plan, the docents—who until recently elected their own officers, were led by a docent board and paid $35 annually in docent dues—will now be part of the general museum volunteer program. The volunteer program includes many free opportunities, but to remain in the docent roles, current docents are asked to join a completely new program: The Art & Community Circle, at the cost of $250 annually. This new program, featuring more than a dozen behind-the-scenes experiences led by curators and staff, is open to all volunteers who would like to pay.
But some docents feel they shouldn’t be asked to pay to volunteer their expertise. “Although the museum says it hasn’t raised docent dues for 11 years, it feels like we’ve been stripped of responsibility, and are being asked to pay several hundred dollars a year—as volunteers—so the museum can hire people to do what we used to do for free,” says Susan Miller, a now former docent.
Museum leaders give several reasons for modifying the program, which will start with a pilot year. This nonprofit is funded by members of this community and relies on local donors, grantors, members and the museum’s endowment. In recent years, most state and federal government funding for museums was eliminated.
“MMA has a small full-time staff, so volunteer hours really make a difference to the visitor experience,” MMA Executive Director Corey Madden writes in an email. “Last year, the museum served more than 25,000 visitors, including 13,000 individuals, families and children who attended completely free of charge. We provided 70 free school tours including bus transportation to 1,646 students and welcomed over 450 military families free of charge. We also host free programming throughout the year including First Fridays, Free Family Fun, the Block Party and Iluminado introducing thousands to California art and creativity.”
Program fees from docents constitute less than 2 percent of the $70,000 that MMA will spend this coming year to train and manage volunteers, Madden adds.
The Monterey Museum of Art is hardly alone in its move to modify its docent program. Moving away from what is perceived as an overly academic culture and opening spaces perceived as elitist to larger communities has been a trend across U.S. cultural institutions, such as museums and libraries.
The broader controversy goes back at least to 2021, when The Art Institute of Chicago disbanded its docent program, replaced partly by paid museum educators and partly by volunteers. In 2022, the Oakland Museum of California discontinued its docent program to expand and diversify its volunteer base, and a year later the Portland Art Museum did the same. None of the above museums require docents to pay, but there are some museums in the U.S. that do. The Tucson Museum of Art requires a $50 membership to start, and the fee for docent training is $225.
The Monterey Museum of Art is offering financial assistance to future docents who can’t pay, and is emphasizing this is a pilot year of the program, open for the community to observe, experience and comment on.