A four-member majority of the Pacific Grove City Council on Wednesday, June 5, rejected Mayor Bill Peake's request to remove Economic Development Commissioner Mike Gibbs from his position, after Gibbs sent an email to another resident disparaging the Diversity, Equity and Inclusion Task Force.

Gibbs also provided personal email addresses of the DEI chair and a former task force member, encouraging the resident, Carol Marquart, to "poke the bear." Both Gibbs and Marquart have been consistent critics of the task force at DEI meetings, council meetings and online since October 2022, around the same time Gibbs launched the conservative group PG Lives.

An unapologetic Gibbs went on the defensive on Wednesday night, arguing that the email addresses he shared were not private and deflecting any criticism by arguing that he and his wife had been subjected to negative comments within the community for the last couple of years. He said he reported some of the comments to Peake but nothing was done about them.

Gibbs was supported by a number of speakers who lauded Gibbs for his contributions as an EDC member and volunteer in the community. Some contended Gibbs' First Amendment rights were being violated, leaving the city open to lawsuits, or predicted economic calamity if the council removed him.

One Gibbs supporter made a disturbing comment in the back of the chamber, according to a witness. After one man spoke to the council urging them to removed Gibbs from his post, the Gibbs supporter said to others: "We should hang him." 

The four councilmembers who voted against removing Gibbs—Luke Coletti, Lori McDonnell, Nick Smith and Debby Beck—said they would have preferred Gibbs received a warning. All were critical of Gibbs' disparaging another city board, but they said they did not have enough evidence before them to vote to remove. 

"I am concerned about some of the language used and I certainly don't want [board, commission and committee] members trying to undermine other commissions in this particular case, given the evidence I'm not able to support the removal," Councilmember Nick Smith said.

Coletti had stronger words for Gibbs.

"What you did, Mike, was really stupid, and I think you know it," Coletti said. "I think your apology was weak and I'd like to see some reconciliation." He also told Gibbs that if he wanted to be an ambassador for the city, he had to support other city boards and commissions.

Coletti also had harsh words for the public.

"There has been a litany of vicious, hateful, spiteful comments made online and towards this body and towards our [boards, commissions and committees], the level of discourse is in the gutter and we need to reset," he said. (Coletti has received negative comments on social media sites Facebook and NextDoor from residents critical of him, as he has also found himself in the midst of controversy.)

Other councilmembers shared their own concerns over the state of public discourse in the town over the last couple of years.

"This has become a tipping point for a problem that's been brewing for years," McDonnell said. She wondered if there was a teachable moment to be had but struggled coming up with an alternative to removing Gibbs that would include an action to address what she said was a systemic problem.

Peake said he was disappointed with negative comments circulating among the public, and while he had no control over what happens outside of City Hall, he was focusing on controlling what went on inside. Gibbs, as a public official, made "antagonistic remarks" against others, Peake said.

Councilmembers Joe Amelio and Chaps Poduri supported Peake's removal request.

Poduri acknowledged Gibbs' service to the community, but he said, "The undermining of another city commission doesn't sit well with me, and that to me is something that we do need to consider."